21 Oct Garmin Alpha Comparison
Elevate your hunting and training game with Garmin GPS dog tracking systems. The secret weapon of hunters and trainers for precise tracking, top-notch training, and stellar visibility. Our guide will lead you to the ideal Garmin tracker, customized for your next thrilling adventure with your four-legged companions!
GARMIN PRODUCTS | ALPHA 10 | ALPHA 100 | ALPHA 200 | ALPHA 200i | ALPHA 300 | ALPHA 300i | ASTRO 430 | PRO 550 PLUS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FEATURES | ||||||||
$399.99 USD | $599.99 USD (Discontinued) | $699.99 USD | $749.99 USD | $799.99 USD | $849.99 USD | $449.99 USD (Discontinued) | $399.99 USD | |
Dimension & Weight | 2.3 x 4.8 x 1.1” (5.8 x 12.1 x 2.9 cm); dimensions do not include antenna160g with standard antenna and spine mount attached | 2.5 x 6.5 x 1.5” (6.4 x 16.5 x 3.8 cm) 250 g with standard antenna and battery | 2.7 x 6.4 x 1.3” (6.8 x 16.2 x 3.4 cm) *dimensions do not include antenna280 g with standard antenna and battery | 62.7 x 6.4 x 1.3” (6.8 x 16.2 x 3.4 cm) *dimensions do not include antenna280 g with standard antenna and battery | 2.4″ x 6.3″ x 1.4″ (6.1 x 16.0 x 3.6 cm) 260.1 g w/ batteries | 1.8″ x 11.4″ x 2.1″ (4.5 x 20.8 x 5.4 cm) 253 g | ||
Display Resolution | 128 x 128 pixels | 240 x 400 pixels | 282 x 470 pixels | 282 x 470 pixels | 160 x 240 pixels | Display resolution: 128 x 128 pixels | ||
Display Type | sunlight-readable, monochrome, transflective memory-in-pixel (MIP) | transflective, 65-K color TFT touchscreen | transflective, color TFT touchscreen | transflective, color TFT touchscreen | transflective, 65-K color TFT | Transflective, monochrome LCD | ||
Display Size | 1.8 in (45 mm) diagonal | 1.53″W x 2.55″H (3.8 x 6.3 cm); 3″ diagonal (7.6 cm) | 1.8″ W x 3.0″ H (4.7 x 7.7 cm); 3.5″ diagonal (88.9 mm) | (WxH) 4.7 cm x 7.7 cm, 3.5″ diagonal (88.9 mm) | 1.43″ x 2.15″ (3.6 x 5.5 cm); 2.6″ (6.6 cm) diagonal | 0.91″ x 0.91″ (2.3 x 2.3 cm); 1.28″ (3.26 cm) diagonal | ||
Battery type: Rechargeable Lithium-Ion | YES (Non- Rechargeable) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Optional NiMH pack or 2 standard AA (not included) | Y |
Battery Life | up to 1 week (40 hours of use) | up to 20 hours | up to 20 hours | up to 20 hours; up to 15 hours with InReach technology enabled | up to 55 hours | up to 55 hours; up to 50 hours with InReach technology enabled | up to 20 hours | 24 hours |
Memory | N/A | 4.0 GB | 16 GB | 16 GB | 4 GB | n/a | ||
Water Rating (7PX) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Touchscreen | N | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | N |
SENSORS Compass: (Tilt-Compensated 3-axis) | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N |
High-sensitivity receiver | (GPS and Galileo) | Only barometric altimeter | GPS , Galileo, & Barometric altimeter | GPS , Galileo, & Barometric altimeter | Only barometric altimeter | Do not have Sensor such as GPS , Galileo, & Barometric altimeter | ||
MAPS & MEMORY Preloaded Maps | N | Topographic | TopaActive | TopaActive | TopaActive | TopaActive | Topo | N |
Ability to add maps | N | Y | Y | Y | Y (see Additional) | Y (see Additional) | Y | N |
Base map | N | Y | Y | Y | N | N | Y | N |
Automatic Routing | N | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | Yes (with optional detailed road mapping) | N |
External memory storage | N | microSD™ card (not included) | microSD™ card (not included) | microSD™ card (not included) | microSD™ card (not included) | microSD™ card (not included) | MicroSD™ card (not included) | N/A |
Navigation Routes | N | 200 | 250 | 250 | 250 | N/A | ||
Waypoints/Favorites/Locations: | N | 4,000 | 10,000 | 2000 | N/A | |||
Tracks | N/A | Tracks up to 20 dogs (TT 10/15/15 mini and T5/5 mini) and buddies (Alpha 100) simultaneously | Up to 20 assets (any combination of compatible dog devices and handhelds) | Tracks: Up to 20 dogs simultaneously | NOT SPECIFIED | |||
Navigation Track Log: | N | 10,000 points, 200 saved tracks | 20,000 points, 200 saved GPS tracks, 300 saved fit activities | 20,000 points, 250 saved GPS tracks, 300 saved fit activities | 20,000 points, 250 saved GPS tracks, 300 saved fit activities | 20,000 points, 250 saved GPS tracks, 300 saved fit activities | 20,000 points, 250 saved GPS tracks, 300 saved fit activities | N/A |
Satellite Imagery | N | N | Satellite Imagery: Yes (direct to device; no annual subscription required) | N/A | ||||
Stored contacts | N | N | 250 dogs | 250 dogs | 250 dogs | 250 dogs | 250 dogs | N/A |
Outdoor Recreation | NOT SPECIFIED | Sun and moon information Custom maps compatible Area calculation Fish forecast | Point to point navigation Sun and moon information Custom maps compatible Area calculation Fish forecast | Point to point navigation Sun and moon information Custom maps compatible Area calculation Fish Forecast | Sun and moon information & Custom maps compatible | Point to point navigation Sun and moon information Custom maps compatible Area calculation Fish Forecast | Geocaching-friendly y(Paperless) Sun and moon information Custom maps compatible fish forecast | N/A |
RADIO FEATURES Frequency | MURS | MURS | MURS | MURS | MURS | MURS | N/A | N/A |
Range | TT and T Series, 9 miles; TT mini and T mini Series, 4 miles | TT 15, 9 miles; Mini, 4 miles | 9 miles with compatible dog devices | 9 miles with compatible dog devices | 9 miles with compatible dog devices | 9 miles with compatible dog devices | (line of sight): T Series: 9 miles; T mini Series: 4 miles | N/A |
Channels | NOT SPECIFIED | NOT SPECIFIED | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | NOT SPECIFIED | NOT SPECIFIED |
Location reporting,(send and receive GPS positions) Vibration alert Contacts | N/A | N/A | Y | Y | Y | Y | N/A | Vibration Alerts |
Compatible with Smart Messenger App | N | N | Y | Y | Y | Y | N | N |
Live Track | N | N | Y | Y | Y | N | N | N |
XERO™ Locations | N | N | Y | Y | N | N | N | N |
Connection | (BLUETOOTH® Low Energy and ANT+®) | Not Specified | Wi-Fi®, BLUETOOTH® and ANT+® | Wi-Fi®, BLUETOOTH® and ANT+® | Wi-Fi®, BLUETOOTH® and ANT+® | Wi-Fi®, BLUETOOTH® and ANT+® | NOT SPECIFIED | NOT SPECIFIED |
Outdoor Applications Garmin Explorer app, Garmin Website, and Dog Tracking | Not Specified | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Not Specified | Garmin explorer App |
INREACH® FEATURES Interactive SOS | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Send and receive text messages to SMS and email | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Send and receive text messages to other InReach device | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Exchange locations with other InReach device | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Virtual keyboard for custom messaging | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Send waypoints to MapShare during trip | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
Send route selection to MapShare during trip | N/A | N/A | N/A | Y | N/A | Y | N/A | N/A |
PROS | Lightweight and budget-friendly GPS tracker Tracks up to 20 dogs from 9 miles away, updating every 2.5 seconds. Water-resistant and easy to use in any weather condition Offers basic training features and needs a smartphone app for mapping. | All-in-One: Combines GPS tracking and e-collar training. Precise Tracking: Real-time updates and point alerts. Durable: Rugged, waterproof, and shockproof. Customizable Training: Extensive settings for training. Advanced Features: Detailed mapping and smartwatch compatibility | Tracks dogs: Up to 9 miles, 2.5-second updates. Dog Management: Easy group and inactive dog handling. Public Land Boundaries: View on maps. Performance Metrics: Track dogs’ speed and distance 18 Stimulation Levels: Customizable training. Tone/Vibration: Quick commands. Garmin Explore App: Real-time tracking and replay. Pro View Compass: Easy dog location tracking. Multi-GNSS: Accurate with GPS and Galileo. TopoActive Maps: Detailed terrain views. BirdsEye Direct: Satellite imagery via Wi-Fi. Navigation Sensors: Altimeter and compass. 20-Hour Battery: Long-lasting. In-Vehicle Tracking: Compatible with Tread® and DriveTrack™. | Text & Social Media: Message and post updates anywhere (satellite subscription needed). SOS Alerts: Send emergency SOS to Garmin’s 24/7 center (subscription required). Location Sharing: Share GPS location or track progress (subscription needed). Global Coverage: Reliable messaging and tracking via Iridium satellite (subscription required).io | Long Battery Life: Up to 55 hours. Clear Touchscreen: 3.5-inch display works with gloves. Advanced Mapping: Includes TopoActive and Garmin Outdoor Maps+. Channel View: Avoids collar interference. Global messaging, navigation, and SOS. Collar Compatibility: Works with new and older collars. | Bright Display: Features a vivid 3.5” touchscreen with a 2.5-second update rate. InReach Satellite Technology: Offers global SOS alerts, two-way messaging, and location tracking. Extended Battery Life: Up to 55 hours, or 50 hours with InReach functionality. Comprehensive Tracking: Tracks up to 20 dogs from distances of up to 9 miles. Enhanced Training Options: Includes 18 levels of stimulation, and commands for tone and vibration. Satellite Imagery: Allows you to download detailed terrain views via Wi-Fi. Efficient Group Management: Supports up to 250 dogs for easier hunting setup. Garmin Explore App Integration: Provides detailed reviews and navigation options. | Quick Updates: 2.5-second location updates for precise tracking Dual Satellite Systems: GPS and GLONASS enhance tracking accuracy. Comprehensive Mapping: Preloaded TOPO U.S. 100K maps and microSD™ slot for additional maps Detailed Hunt Metrics: Tracks and analyzes hunting performance and behavior. Covey Counter™: Records specific hunting details, including prey locations and counts. Wireless Sharing: Supports data transfer with various Garmin devices and watches. Durable Design: Water-resistant to IPX7 and rugged enough for field conditions. | Versatile Training Options: 18 stimulation levels with tone and vibration for effective dog training. Rapid Tracking Updates: 2.5-second location updates ensure accurate tracking of fast-moving dogs. Extended Battery Life: 24-hour battery capacity supports long hunts and training sessions. Built to Last: Durable and water-resistant design handles rugged conditions. Enhanced Tracking: Compatible with various Garmin devices for extended tracking capabilities. App Integration: Garmin Explore™ app compatibility allows for detailed tracking and data storage on mobile devices. |
CONS | Basic Training Features: Limited stimulation and controls. No Built-In Mapping: Requires app or other devices for maps. No Touchscreen: Lacks touchscreen functionality. Fewer Advanced Features: Less versatile compared to higher-end models. | Complex Interface: Slow adjustments and navigation via touchscreen. Limited Buttons: Only three training buttons. No Beeper: Lacks beeper compatibility for dense cover. High Cost: $599.99 may be pricey for some users. | Battery Life: Shorter compared to some devices, which may require more frequent recharging. Cost: Priced at $699.99, which might be high for some users. No Collars Included: Collars must be purchased separately. Complexity: Advanced features might be overwhelming for some users. Additional Costs: Some map features and accessories are sold separately. | Has a higher Price: If you’re buying Alpha 200i handheld with dog device, the price is $1,099.99 for the TT 15x and $1,049.99 for the T 5x Shorter Battery life when using in reach Requires compatible Garmin products for full functionality. | Cost: High price may be a barrier for some users. Complexity: Advanced features might be overwhelming for beginners. Size/Weight: Slightly bulky, which could affect portability. Ongoing Costs: Premium map features require a subscription. Battery Replacement: In-field battery replacement can be inconvenient Interference: Potential signal issues in densely packed areas. | High Cost: At $849.99, it’s on the pricier side. Feature Complexity: Advanced functions might be overwhelming for new users Separate Purchase Required: Collars are sold separately. Additional InReach Costs: May require a subscription for full satellite features. In-Field Battery Replacement: May be inconvenient during hunts. | High Cost: Advanced features and compatibility might come at a premium price. Collars Sold Separately: Requires additional purchase of compatible collars. Limited International Availability: Approved for use only in the U.S., with restrictions in Canada. Complex Features: Might be overwhelming for users unfamiliar with advanced tracking systems. Battery Options: Requires standard AA batteries or optional rechargeable NiMH pack; in-field battery management can be a hassle. | Additional Purchases Required: Compatible dog collars are sold separately. Price Point: $399.99 may be high for casual users. Limited Dog Capacity: Tracks up to 3 dogs; not ideal for larger packs. Complexity for Beginners: Advanced features may require a learning curve for new users. |
Additional | Track storage: up to 10 days | Frequency band: MURS (The T 5, T 5 mini, TT™ 15 and TT 15 mini are only compatible with the Astro® 320 and the Alpha™ 100. The T 5, T 5 mini, TT 15 and TT 15 mini can be configured for operation with either handheld but cannot be tracked simultaneously by both the Astro 320 and the Alpha 100.) Tracks up to 20 dogs (TT 10/15/15 mini and T5/5 mini) and buddies (Alpha 100) simultaneously *Garmin discontinued the Alpha 100 to focus on newer technology and market trends. The Alpha 200 and 300 models offer enhanced features and performance, meeting evolving consumer needs. By phasing out the Alpha 100, Garmin can streamline production, cut support costs, and stay competitive with advanced products. This approach ensures Garmin remains innovative and resource-efficient. Despite its discontinuation, the Alpha 100 is still available through businesses on platforms like Amazon, eBay, and local stores. | Ability to add maps: yes (Outdoor Maps+ | Ability to add maps: yes (Outdoor Maps+ | Range (line of sight): T Series: 9 miles; T mini Series: 4 miles Frequency band: The T Series and the TT Series dog collars cannot be tracked simultaneously by both the Astro 320 and Astro 430. Handhelds vibration mode: yes Tracks up to 20 dogs simultaneously *Garmin discontinued the Astro 430 to focus on newer, better technology. As Garmin developed more advanced models, the Astro 430 became outdated. Newer models offer improved GPS accuracy, better maps, and longer battery life. Keeping older models like the Astro 430 can be expensive for Garmin, so it makes sense for them to invest in new technology. This move helps Garmin stay competitive and meet the latest demands of their customers, ensuring they continue to provide top-notch, up-to-date products. |
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.